Secure Sockets Layer

Welcome

Hello Guest
Did you know this forum has been running since 2010?
DataBot

DataBot

Our bot discovers modern tech on the web and then posts about it in the forum.

Recent Topics

Stop Burning Stuff

Octopus

Can You Help?

Help keep our site running
Advert free.

Web Utilities

Technology

Perpetual Motion

Started by DD1975, December 16, 2012, 23:30:26 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic. Total views: 7,211

DaveMorton

You know what gets me about the people on the telly who try to describe the 2nd law? They always use the example of "bridges rust", when that's patently untrue, for several reasons:

1.) the law postulates the advance of entropy in a closed system, and a bridge over a river (or even sitting in the middle of the desert, or even in space, for that matter) cannot be in a "closed system", because, by definition, a closed system has no outside forces acting upon it,

2.) even if said bridge was floating in space, where it can't be acted upon by the atmosphere, causing it to "rust" over time (what if it's an aluminum bridge? can't rust!), there are still outside forces acting upon iit. Plus, it's not going to corrode while in space, will it? :P

"bridges rust", my aunt Fannie!
Safe, Reliable Insanity, Since 1961!

Snowcrash

Aluminium (aluminum) corrodes in salt air. Technically only iron rusts.

The universe is a closed system. Entropy always increases. The only blip is systems far from equilibrium, most notibly; life.
Life can maintain order only by the constant flow of energy (food). Entropy always wins in the end.
"I cannot remember the books I've read any more than the meals I have eaten; even so, they have made me."

Ralph Waldo Emerson

DaveMorton

Oh, I'm not refuting the second law at all, Snowy. I'm just pointing out that they're using a flawed example, based on faulty nomenclature. And of course the Universe is a closed system, since there's nothing "outside" to influence things. Unless, of course, you take string theory into account along with multiple universes co-existing side by side, where the membranes between the two can be potentially disturbed, allowing things to "leak" from one to another and back. But that's highly theoretical stuff, and not widely accepted. :)
Safe, Reliable Insanity, Since 1961!

Snowcrash

Space corrosion is generally called ablation. It is degradation by high energy particles from the solar wind and cosmic rays.

Most unity gain devices get their extra energy from somewhere else not specified in the device.

There is no such thing as a free lunch but the universe gets pretty close. (S.Hawking)
"I cannot remember the books I've read any more than the meals I have eaten; even so, they have made me."

Ralph Waldo Emerson

DD1975

Quote from: Snowcrash on December 17, 2012, 22:28:07 PM
And as for perpetual motion. 2lot, it's the law. (2nd law of thrmodynamics, the reason perpetual motion can't work)

Laws are there to be bent, broken or re-written  :thumbsup:
Smoke me a Kipper I'll be back for breakfast - Ace Rimmer